Metroid Prime 4 Review — Good Shooter, Questionable Metroid
Share
I have played more Metroid games than most, so when I talk about Metroid Prime 4, I’d like to think I have something worthwhile to say. Although this game feels like a Prime game, and it obviously looks like a Samus Aran game, there are some extremely questionable game design choices that completely kill that Metroid Prime feel.
One of the addictive characteristics of Metroid is wanting to go about and explore, find some hidden goodies, upgrade yourself, and become more badass with each one. It’s almost like a strong subplot to these games. It’s just addicting turning overpowered!
But in this game? It was a chore.
Exploration was built into the game in a way where so much of it just wasn’t something I was doing out of my own volition. There is sooo much to say here, and I’m grumpy as hell today.
I don’t even know where to start. Oh my god. Let’s just go with the easiest thing to punch at.
Sol Valley was so barren and dull, you’d think you were on Tatooine without the podracing, gambling, and intelligent aliens. There is nothing there but some annoying little balls that come chase after you every now and then, and some annoying green birds that you simply hold the “A” button to dispose of. Then you got some green little piles of rocks you can smash through if you’d like. It’s somewhat satisfying until you gotta get off your bike to finish off the stash. That gets annoying quickly.
There just ain’t anything in Sol Valley! It feels like something forced upon the developers because open-world was what everyone was about and somebody decided Metroid needed a big open area too.
It didn’t work, homies.
I wanna talk about game mechanics next. I personally played with motion controls since I’ve been familiar with that style for Switch games thus far. I truly enjoyed it, and it felt much more engaging than the previous style of locking on and spamming shoot.
But hollllyyyy mollyyyy.
You can Lock-On and Dash side-to-side during combat, but this becomes completely frustrating with motion controls because I constantly have to disengage Lock-On whenever I want to manually aim again. Otherwise, it throws me into that mouse-style aiming and I can’t aim for s*** in that mode! But Dash is such an important part of combat, so you WILL need to lock on.
The mechanics on their own are great. Together? Yikes.
And until you upgrade your damage output, the arm cannon initially feels so damn unimpactful. Sometimes you’ll legitimately be confused about whether your shots are even doing anything. They’re like spitting pellets onto the enemy. I just think that could have been done better. The upgrades felt much more substantial to me in the previous games.
The audio in this game is seexxyy! It’s always been good, but with the hardware improvements we have now, it’s even better. That’s why the beginning can feel so strange when you’re shooting enemies, because the audio just isn’t supporting the impact of the arm cannon the way you’d expect. Once you upgrade it, though, everything becomes much more immersive.
On top of that, the music is fantastic for setting up the atmosphere. Fury Green is deffffff a favourite of mine. Also, the pinball effects?? Soooo satisfying.
They really kill it in the audio department.
Which brings me to some of the voices you will constantly hear. MacKenzie and crew got some decent voice acting to them, but it gets mad weird having Samus standing around these people and just... not speaking. At some point, you start wondering why she cannot be voiced. You can hear her speaking in Ravenous and it works, so hearing everybody around her talking while Samus just kinda stands there becomes increasingly awkward.
I also don’t know if I particularly like MacKenzie. I like how smart he is. I like him as a character. But constantly hearing his goofy voice telling me what to do next started irking me.
In fact, I gotta blow up again.
Metroid makes you backtrack, but we’re not talking about the GOOD Metroid kind of backtracking here. We’re talking redundant, forced, main-story backtracking.
So you got a new upgrade and remember that one room that needed it? And now you’re super excited to go check it out?
Sorry. That wasn’t for you to figure out. That was for MacKenzie to tell you that’s what you’re supposed to do next while you’re already three quarters of the way there.
This game is the most linear Metroid I have ever played. It’s disgusting.
Previous Metroid Prime games give you a lottttt of room to explore using your own neurons to remember what locations needed what ability. You unlock something new, something clicks in your head, and now you wanna go see what the hell was hiding behind that door from three hours ago.
But no. This game has Wolverine’s Scent right on it through MacKenzie’s breath. The game constantly wants to make sure you know where to go and what to do next instead of trusting you to just explore and figure shit out.
By the way, when you’re ACTUALLY lost and don’t know what to do next, guess who suddenly isn’t available on the radio to ask? Yea buddy. You guessed it. MacKenzie. But he sure as s*** will be back on the radio to tell you what you are already doing again.
And can we talk about the redundant scanning? I get it when we need to scan things like the Lamorn statues or something actually relevant to figuring out the world. That makes sense. But dashboards? Elevator switches that I then have to press “A” on immediately afterward anyways?
Come on now.
I just want you to imagine coming home, knowing your key fob is what opens the door, but every single time you arrive you have to stare at the damn key fob for ten seconds, wait for permission, and THEN use it to open the door.
That’s what this feels like. It is just so unnecessary, and I don’t know why they didn’t stop doing that after the tutorial or something.
But there’s still some good.
Just like I mentioned the audio, I also really enjoyed the Great Mines. In fact, this was probably my favourite section of the game. If Nintendo wants to move Metroid Prime in a more action-oriented direction, THIS level showed a great way to do it Metroid style. More combat. More pressure. More things actually happening around you. It didn’t feel like they were trying to make Metroid into something else. It still felt like Metroid, just with the action turned up.
I also really enjoyed the boss battles in this game.
They can get pretty difficult, but it was such a great feeling to actually be challenged by a game and have to lock in. I find way too many games are made too easy these days, aside from the notorious Dark Souls-type games, so having bosses that still pack a punch was refreshing. It don’t even matter how many upgrades you got going. Some of these boss battles can prove to be a bi***!
But again...
I told you I’m in a grumpy mood today.
Factor in that I already mentioned redundancy, linearity, and MacKenzie.
Do you remember those green crystals?
THEY ARE NOT A SIDE QUEST.
THEY ARE PART OF THE STORY.
I GASPED when I was told I had to collect enough of those damn things to fill up a Memory Fruit.
Luckily, there were some game sessions where I was too tired to use my brain, so I simply drove around collecting some of them while exploring Sol Boring. Because of that, it wasn’t too bad when I eventually had to go back out there and get the rest.
But can you imagine reaching this part of the game and you never bothered with the green crystals? You would literally have to drive around collecting these things just to get the story moving again.
And you think I’m done with this topic?
Nooppee!
Right after that, you gotta go collect some Mech Parts that were only mentioned in passing once near the beginning of the game.
So AGAIN, when you go explore on your own, it almost feels like it’s for naught. You’ll come across some things naturally while exploring and eventually the game tells you when you’re allowed to go get them.
There is no free will in this game. It is one long path.
It is honestly mind-boggling to me that both the green crystals and the Mech Parts, two things that felt eerily like side quest content, ended up becoming mandatory story quests.
It was such a mistake to make errands part of the main story.
Those things should have been left to the player’s discretion and rewarded you for going out of your way to explore. Give me a weapon upgrade. Give me extra health. Give me something what the hell. Something. Like why bring the story to a complete halt so I can go do activities that don’t even feel like Metroid?
Now, I know I’ve sounded super grumpy about this game and like I’m about to give it a cheeks out of ten, but I still had a lot of fun playing it. And I think that’s what makes this one frustrating. Metroid in 3D works. Metroid as a shooter works. We already saw it with the first three Prime games and even Hunters on the DS. I absolutely still think there is room for a 3D Metroid shooter.
I just don’t know if continuing the Prime formula exactly as it is should be the answer anymore.
Maybe it is time to finish the Prime story and rebuild something new around Samus. Because the shooting works. The bosses work. The atmosphere works when the game actually lets it breathe. The Great Mines showed me that a more action-heavy Metroid can absolutely work too.
But Metroid Prime 4 just ain’t it.
It’s a good action shooter. But as a Metroid game? This ain’t the quality I expected.
Mr. Grumpy